Top 5 Reciprocating Saws

David Smith

Updated on:

Reciprocating Saws

When it comes to power and versatility, reciprocating saws stand out as indispensable tools for metal and woodworking enthusiasts. These tools, equipped with a straight, serrated blade and an ergonomic handle, offer a combination of precision and power that makes them a must-have in any toolkit. In this guide, we’ll explore the top-rated reciprocating saws on the market, providing you with detailed insights to help you make an informed decision.

Reciprocating Saw
Reciprocating Saw

Top 5 Reciprocating Saws

Best Overall: DEWALT 20-Volt Reciprocating Saw

DEWALT DCS367B 20V Max XR Brushless Compact Reciprocating Saw, (Tool Only) and DW4856 Metal/Woodcutting Reciprocating Saw Blade Set, 6-Piece
  • Compact and lightweight design
  • Variable speed trigger with 0-2900 SPM
  • Pivoting shoe
  • Combination set provides a selection of blades for common applications
  • Compatible with all reciprocating saw brands

Our top pick, the DEWALT 20-Volt Reciprocating Saw, takes the crown for its outstanding features. With a speed of 2900 strokes per minute (SPM), a 20-volt voltage, and a mere 5.4 pounds weight, this saw delivers unmatched performance. The 3-year limited warranty adds an extra layer of confidence for users. Customer reviews highlight its versatility and impressive ability to cut through various materials. While some users noted excessive vibration, the overall consensus is its compact size and high power level make it a winner.

Most Versatile Saw: WORX 20-Volt Reciprocating Saw

WORX WG320 JawSaw 20V PowerShare Cordless Electric Chainsaw with Auto-Tension with WX550L.9 20V AXIS 2-in-1 Reciprocating Saw and Jigsaw with Orbital Mode, Variable Speed and Tool-Free Blade Change
  • [KIT INCLUDES] WORX 20V Power Share Jaw Saw and Extra Power Share 20V 4.0Ah Battery
  • [ADDED SAFETY] The JawSaw features a fully protective guard. When not in use the blade retracts into the base. And because of that guard, this is the only chainsaw made for cutting directly on the ground. Leave the log right there on the pavement and get to work
  • [CUTS UP TO 4”] Saw through material up to 4 inches in diameter. And with its innovative single-action cutting mechanism you’ve never had so much cutting power that was so easy to use
  • [LIGHT ENOUGH TO USE OVERHEAD] The Worx JawSaw weighs 7.9 lbs. with the battery attached. Not only is that light for a chainsaw; the even weight distribution, and safety jaw guard, bolster the tool and make it easy to maneuver around overhead branches
  • [2 SAWS IN 1] Pivoting, push-button head turns your jigsaw into a reciprocating saw and back again in just a few seconds

WORX’s 20-Volt Reciprocating Saw earns its place as the most versatile. Boasting a speed of 3000 SPM, 20-volt voltage, and a lightweight 4.6 pounds design, this saw is a favorite among users for its easy-to-use design and durable construction. Some users, however, expressed frustration with the battery’s run time and its efficiency on larger projects. Despite these concerns, the WORX saw stands out for its versatility and durability.

Best Compact Saw: PORTER-CABLE 20-Volt Reciprocating Saw

PORTER-CABLE 20V MAX* Oscillating Tool (PCC710B) and 20V MAX* Reciprocating Saw (PCC670B)
  • Oscillating tool has 2 finger tool-free system for quick accessory changes; Reciprocating saw has tool-free blade release for quick changes.
  • Oscillating tool has variable speed dial from 8K to 18K OPM for control across applications; Reciprocating saw has variable speed trigger for cutting variety of materials.
  • Oscillating tool has LED work light for visibility in dark conditions.
  • Reciprocating saw delivers up to 3,000 SPM with 1 inch stroke length to help finish jobs quickly.
  • Reciprocating saw has compact 14.5 inch length to access tight spaces.

For those valuing maneuverability and efficiency, the PORTER-CABLE 20-Volt Reciprocating Saw is the go-to choice. Weighing only 3.75 pounds and featuring a variable speed trigger, it provides a customizable experience. Positive customer reviews commend its maneuverability and power level. However, it’s essential to note that a portion of users reported malfunctions and a shorter lifespan than expected. The absence of a battery in the package disappointed some buyers.

Best Budget Saw: BLACK+DECKER 20V Cordless Reciprocating Saw

BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX Reciprocating Saw with Lithium Battery & Charger (BDCR20B & LBXR20CK)
  • Tool Free Blade Change; Battery and charger sold separately
  • Pivoting Shoe
  • Maximum initial battery voltage (measured without a workload) is 20 volts; Nominal voltage is 18.
  • Complete all-in-one charging solution
  • Versatility and convenience

Balancing affordability and performance, the BLACK+DECKER 20V Cordless Reciprocating Saw is a solid choice. With a speed of 3000 SPM, 20-volt voltage, and a weight of 4.5 pounds, it offers versatility and durability. Positive reviews emphasize its lightweight design and ease of use. Some users, however, mentioned concerns about the battery’s lifespan and excessive vibration during operation.

Most Ergonomic Saw: Makita 18-Volt Cordless Reciprocating Saw

Makita BL1840BDC2 18V LXT Lithium-Ion Battery and Rapid Optimum Charger Starter Pack (4.0Ah) with XRJ04Z 18V LXT Lithium-Ion Cordless Recipro Saw
  • XRJ04Z - Makita-built variable speed motor delivers 0-2,800 strokes per minute and a 1-1/4 inches stroke length for faster cutting and variable speed trigger for added convenience
  • XRJ04Z - "Tool-less" blade change system allows for faster blade installation and removal for increased productivity and compact and ergonomic design at only 19-1/8 inches long
  • XRJ04Z - Weighs only 8.3 pounds with battery for reduced operator fatigue and rubberized soft grip handle provides increased comfort on the job
  • XRJ04Z - Refined crank mechanism design minimizes blade deflection and reduces vibration and large two-finger trigger for operator convenience
  • BL1840BDC2 - 18V LXT Lithium-Ion 4.0Ah battery reaches a full charge in 40 minutes or less and provides up to 35% more run time per charge compared to BL1830

Makita’s 18-Volt Cordless Reciprocating Saw excels in ergonomic design and power. Operating at 2800 SPM, with an 18-volt voltage and weighing 8 pounds, it provides a balanced and easy operation. Users appreciate its power and quick operation. Yet, a few encountered challenges finding a compatible battery charger, and some wished for adjustable cutting depths. Despite these drawbacks, Makita’s saw is a solid choice for those prioritizing ergonomic design.

What Customers Are Saying

DEWALT 20-Volt Reciprocating Saw

Customers praised its versatility and ability to cut through different materials. Some noted excessive vibration and insufficient power for heavy wood.

Also read: How to Use Voltage Tester Pen

WORX 20-Volt Reciprocating Saw

Users appreciated its lightweight and easy-to-use design. Concerns were raised about the battery’s run time on larger projects.

PORTER-CABLE 20-Volt Reciprocating Saw

Positive reviews highlighted maneuverability and power, while some users reported malfunctions and disappointment over the absence of a battery.

BLACK+DECKER 20V Cordless Reciprocating Saw

Buyers were satisfied with its versatile design and lightweight. Complaints included a short-lasting battery and discomfort due to vibration.

Makita 18-Volt Cordless Reciprocating Saw

Customers liked its balanced operation and power but faced challenges finding a compatible battery charger and desired adjustable cutting depths.

Also read: DeWalt 20V Max XR Impact Driver Review DCF845

Reciprocating Saw Buying Guide

Corded vs. Cordless Reciprocating Saws

Choosing between corded and cordless reciprocating saws depends on your needs. Corded saws offer more power but limited mobility, while cordless options provide convenience and longer battery life.

Also read: Best Electrician Backpack

Speed Settings

A saw’s speed, measured in SPM, affects its cutting motion. Variable-speed triggers allow for customized cutting, adjusting to different applications with increased pressure.

Sawing Motion

Reciprocating saws typically use a push-pull motion, but some models feature orbital cutting for enhanced efficiency.

Battery Life

The battery life of cordless saws, often 20-volt, impacts project duration, with variations based on type, model, and usage.

Best Reciprocating Saws
Best Reciprocating Saws

How We Selected the Best Reciprocating Saws

To ensure our readers receive the most accurate and comprehensive recommendations, our selection process involves:

Initial Research

We compiled a list of reciprocating saws with a substantial number of verified-buyer reviews, focusing on those with a customer review rating of 4–5 stars. Both positive and negative reviews were analyzed to gain insights into user experiences.

Expert Insights

Drawing on our years of experience, we supplemented our in-house expertise by reviewing insights from trusted publications, independent testers, and subject matter experts. By considering a variety of perspectives, we ensured a well-rounded evaluation.

Final Product Selection

We refined our list by replacing outdated models with the latest versions and eliminating discontinued options. A thorough comparison of each model’s features led to the selection of the best-in-class reciprocating saws, catering to different buyers, budgets, and scenarios.

Also read: Best Chainsaw Chains

10 Questions and Answers Related to Reciprocating Saws

1. Q: Can reciprocating saws cut through metal?

A: Absolutely, reciprocating saws are designed for cutting through a variety of materials, including metal.

2. Q: Are reciprocating saws suitable for fine woodworking?

A: While they excel in rough cuts, reciprocating saws may not be the best choice for fine woodworking. Consider other saw types for precision.

3. Q: How long do reciprocating saw blades last?

A: The lifespan of blades varies based on usage and material. Regularly replacing blades ensures optimal performance.

4. Q: Can I use a reciprocating saw for pruning trees?

A: Yes, reciprocating saws can be effective for pruning small branches. Ensure you use the right blade for the job.

5. Q: What safety precautions should I take when using a reciprocating saw?

A: Wear appropriate safety gear, secure your workpiece, and follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for safe operation.

6. Q: Can I use any reciprocating saw blade with my saw?

A: While many blades are interchangeable, it’s crucial to use the right blade for the material you’re cutting for optimal results.

7. Q: Do reciprocating saws come with adjustable speed settings?

A: Yes, most reciprocating saws feature variable-speed triggers, allowing you to adjust the cutting speed for different applications.

8. Q: Are cordless reciprocating saws as powerful as corded ones?

A: While corded saws generally offer more power, advancements in battery technology make cordless options powerful and convenient for various tasks.

9. Q: Can reciprocating saws replace other saw types in a toolkit?

A: Reciprocating saws are versatile, but for specific tasks like precision cuts or detailed woodworking, other saw types may be more suitable.

10. Q: How do I maintain my reciprocating saw for optimal performance?

A: Regularly clean the tool, lubricate moving parts, and follow the manufacturer’s maintenance guidelines to ensure longevity and performance.

3 thoughts on “Top 5 Reciprocating Saws”

Leave a Comment